The Iwata Principle

In June 2013, a shareholder at Nintendo's annual meeting pointed at two years of operating losses and suggested corporate restructuring. Satoru Iwata, then the company's president, answered in public. Laying off a group of employees, he said, will not help strengthen the business in the long run. And he doubted that people who fear for their jobs can make software that impresses the world.

// the crux

Before you ask anyone else to carry a cost, carry yours first, and say in public what you will not do.

// in one breath

A shareholder asked the president of a loss-making company to restructure. His answer, and the pay cut two years before it, show an order of decisions worth stealing.

What the record shows

Two years earlier, in July 2011, Nintendo cut the price of the 3DS and lowered its forecast. It announced something else the same day: fixed pay down 50% for the president, 30% for the other representative directors and 20% for the other directors. For the year to March 2012 no performance bonus was paid to directors, because operating income was negative. Iwata's own total came to 45 million yen. Employees were not left untouched, and he said so: their bonuses had been reduced to some extent.

The version of this story that circulates online says a chief executive halved his salary to avoid layoffs. Nintendo's own pages, which I read for this essay, support a narrower claim that I find more useful. They show the order of the decisions. The leaders' pay moved first and furthest. The question of layoffs was answered no, in public, in front of shareholders. The cost the company still had to carry was named, including a trim to employee bonuses. I found no page where Iwata links the pay cut to saving jobs. That link is mine, and I think it is the right one to draw.

The order is the principle

When a cost has to be carried, the leader's own pay is the first line on the list and other people's jobs are the last. The reason is what each order teaches the room. If the cut starts at the bottom, everyone learns that cost runs downhill and that the person who made the call is the best protected from it. If it starts at the top, the next request has already been paid for in credibility. People will carry a hard quarter for someone who visibly carried it first.

Iwata gave the business reason himself, and it is an engineer's argument. Software is made by attention, and fear takes attention first. A team that spends its days wondering whether the next round includes them is not going to produce its best work, and the loss shows up in the product long before it shows up in a spreadsheet.

Where the principle stops

This is not a rule that no team may ever be cut. Iwata acknowledged in the same answer that some companies restructure, and sometimes they have to. It is a rule about sequence and about honesty. The cheap options come first, which in his words meant cutting unnecessary expenses and raising efficiency. The leader's pay comes before anyone's job. And whatever is left to carry gets a plain account, including the parts that still land on employees, as the bonus reduction did.

The test fits in one question. Before you announce what the team must carry, can you say what you have already put down?

// continue exploring